KFFL.com - Free fantasy football, baseball and NASCAR

Fantasy Sports Blog

Fantasy Football, Baseball, NASCAR, Basketball and Hockey Tips, News and Strategy

Chicago Bears running back Matt Forte is overvalued!

By William Del Pilar on July 7, 2009
Filed Under: Del Pilar's Diatribe, Fantasy Football, NFL

william-del-pilar-diatribe

I must say, it was a wonderful Fourth of July and I hope everyone not only enjoyed it but partied late into the evening and partied safely. The weather was gorgeous here in beautiful San Diego, but I live in the country, and the temperature was a little warmer than I would have liked. You can’t win them all.

We’re getting closer to the beginning of the season, and more and more drafts are happening. My staff, as always, is taking part in many of them, officially representing KFFL. As a private citizen, I’ve taken it upon myself to sign up for the NFFC and the WCOFF high-stakes leagues again this year.

I’m on a mission this year. The better half is never happy if I’m not in the top portion of any ranking of any contests I play in. Simply put, she views it as a waste of our money. I guess I can’t blame her! In response to that, I’ve finally begun to dig into the numbers and will have some projections soon enough.

Don’t forget to check out KFFL’s projections as they’re solid as well, and if you have questions about or issues with them, let them know. I always have enjoyed reading feedback on projections because it makes you think. In fact, I believe that is how projections can improve. You can never improve a service when someone is always complimenting the organization. You improve when someone gives you feedback and questions what you’re doing.

Enough of that! In reviewing e-mails I’ve seen since getting back, I came across one asking the following question:

  • Who is the most overvalued player so far?

The original word was “overrated,” but I hate that word. I would rather use the word “overvalued.” In response to that question, I think Matt Forte is overvalued this year. He’s a nice back, but many of us who saw him play last season would not say he’s a top-tier, stud running back. I think players who are taking him at his average draft position (ADP) will regret it at season’s end when he’s compared with other running backs.

matt-forte-391x213-20090324a

Is any first-round fantasy football player more overvalued than Matt Forte?

In looking at Mock Draft Central’s ADP, right now he’s going 2.41 overall in point-per-reception (PPR) leagues and 2.50 in NFL performance (non-PPR) leagues. The high and low in PPR leagues are No. 1 and No. 4, respectively. In non-PPR leagues, they’re No. 1 and No. 5.

I have no issues with Forte and actually am a big fan. I love it when players without superstar talent excel and show they not only can play with the big boys but excel as well. He is that type of player. He is fundamentally sound and maximizes his talent. Sadly, I thought last season may eventually be seen as one of his best.

This year, I have concerns based on where he’s going – not on what he can do. I see newly acquired quarterback Jay Cutler not doing as many checkdown passes as Kyle Orton did. If you watched them play last year, you would know the team put Orton in that position because they were conservative with him and did not want to go downfield as much. That created much wear and tear with Forte as well. This raises the question of whether he was overworked last year and if it will affect him this year. He’s young, so many will say no, but until we see him play this year, we won’t know for sure. I would err on the side of caution.

I look for the team to open it up more and for the receivers and tight ends to see a jump in their receptions. That will come at the expense of Forte. His defenders will say, with Cutler behind center, defenses will not stack the box. While that may be true, I don’t see that theory as being valid enough to take him No. 1 overall or even in the top three to five. I won’t dispute that he is a middle- to late-first-round pick, but he’s not the overall No. 1.

The KFFL team stated it best when they pointed out that he failed to rush for more than 70 yards in seven different games. Also, his 100-plus yard games came against some weak teams last season. Specifically, they were the Indianapolis Colts, Detroit Lions and St. Louis Rams.

If I have a high first-round pick, I’m trading down because he’s not the only player going high that I question this year. I haven’t seen so many first-round question marks in all my years of playing; I’m not kidding when I say that. This year’s first-round picks will have a lot of say in who wins their championships. That is, anyone from the top pick to the No. 12 pick could wind up the league’s best fantasy player!

Let me know your thoughts, and if you disagree, why? If you agree, who do you see as No. 2? I assume Adrian Peterson is this year’s top pick.

As always, if you’re looking for breaking news updates that get to you faster than e-mail, follow me on Twitter at http://twitter.com/wdelpilar.

KFFLians think:

No. 1 
John Bishop on 07/07/2009 @ 1:34 pm wrote:

Let’s play in a league together this year! I may not be as popular as you are at this point, but my seven championships in the last eight years speak for themselves. I don’t want to give myself away too much, because I have a lot of drafting to do this season, but I think your way off base with Forte. Number one, regardless of the Cutler factor, the Bears still have one of better offensive lines in all of football. Number two, they still play the Lions twice,as well as the Falcons,Cards,and Rams, and only have around 5 games all year against what I would consider top 10 defenses. Number three, their own defense, which again has the potential to be the top defense this year, will have their offense on the field a lot as well. All things considered, I have to rank Forte as my second pick overall. As you said though, the top twelve, and I might even venture to say possibly the top 15 overall this season, could very well have lots of potential. But based on the factors I have stated, I believe Forte has to be a solid 2nd choice to Peterson.


No. 2 
fazsha on 07/07/2009 @ 2:03 pm wrote:

To a certain degree I agree that Forte is overvalued. It will be impossible to say for sure, though, until he plays behind Cutler. Cutler will keep defenses honest, and I think that if Forte is to shine, it will be in 2009 or not at all. He’s very smooth, and is able to get the most out of a run, though he doesn’t have a lot of make-you-miss.


No. 3 
troy on 07/07/2009 @ 6:29 pm wrote:

i couldnt agree more with this post….I would add that kevin jones is DEFINITELY going to get more work….jones should end up with 100-150 carries this year. PLUS, ron turner already showed last year that he isnt necessarily willing to put forte in on goaline situations…so its hard to see how the other AP or mckie wont continue to limit his touchdown potential


No. 4 
Matt on 07/08/2009 @ 9:24 am wrote:

As a Bears fan I hope Forte has a big year, of course, but I do agree that 1-3 is a little high to take him given potential advances in the passing game and Kevin Jones’ expanding role. (Again, all of which are also good things for me as a Bears fan.)

The thing you didn’t mention, though, that I think does make him a valid #4-5 is the upgrades that the Bears have made at offensive line this year. I expect that make a difference when it comes to his yards per carry average, especially against stronger defenses, as you noted.


No. 5 
Pash on 07/09/2009 @ 7:38 pm wrote:

I can’t disagree that Forte is a little overvalued this year. That said, I have him # 3 or # 4.

I can find an argument for MJD. I can find an argument for Turner…. and I can find an argument for LT.

The thing is, warning signs for Turner are that the league figured his FIRTST year out, (and that history for a ridiculous workload does not bode well for the following year), and that LT may or may not be done (see: Alexander, Sean…. Johnson, Larry)….

I can see MJD. Young… awesome… hungry…. healthy… But besides him, I see Forte with SEVEN in the box instead of EIGHT getting better.

A clear #3.


No. 6 
Cyrus on 07/16/2009 @ 12:39 pm wrote:

We agree that Forte is overrated at the 2 spot – we like MJD there.


Trackbacks

  1. The Bears Den - 7/8/09  on July 8th, 2009 @ 2:17 am
Home: Return to KFFL.com's Fantasy Sports Blog