KFFL's staffers choose their favorite 2011 overvalued fantasy baseball players.
Cory J. Bonini
| Player |
POS |
TM |
The what for |
| Rickie Weeks |
2B |
MIL |
Still a major injury risk. Recently signed a large contract and could become complacent; SBs just a bonus; let someone else assume the risk. |
| Alfonso Soriano |
OF |
CHC |
Limited steals potential, major injury risk, age and a pedestrian BA all point me toward younger, potentially more explosive options. |
| Michael Bourn |
OF |
HOU |
Never a fan of relying heavily on players with limited contribution ability. Bourn's bags and runs are nice, but don't overpay for the swipe category. |
| Jonathan Sanchez |
SP |
SF |
Fly-ball and walk issues are a concern; high, unsustainable LOB rate last year (79.5), IP jump and late-season regression a concern. |
| Matt Garza |
SP |
CHC |
Temper your expectations, that's all. Move to NL intriguing but not the be all, end all. Fly-ball rate and HR/9 three straight years of northbound travel. |
Nicholas Minnix
| Player |
POS |
TM |
The what for |
| Ichiro Suzuki |
OF |
SEA |
Very good player, just not interested in 37-YO's - safe, definitely pretty safe - .300 BA and 30-35 SB in high number of AB at cost anymore. |
| Jose Bautista |
3B/OF |
TOR |
He'll play, hit bunch of HR. But 2010 value was in diff-making roto FA acquisition; 2011 price means, to break even, MUST hit the ~35 folks project. |
| Rickie Weeks |
2B |
MIL |
Puts together outstanding full season; therefore, is cured of injury tendency. Wish it worked that way. Rather pay less for Ian Kinsler in MLB universe. |
| Stephen Drew |
SS |
ARI |
Another good player, but I don't anticipate his stat lines matching his talent in most years. If I wait that long on SS, I'll just wait a little longer. |
| Jonathan Sanchez |
SP |
SF |
Member of WS winner pitching later in year. Fairly taxing season, BB/9 issues and last year's hit percentage fortune make me less interested. |
Tim Heaney
| Player |
POS |
TM |
The what for |
| Ichiro Suzuki |
OF |
SEA |
Not worth building your draft around Ichiro anymore. BA less helpful. Lineup doesn't help R. This aging machine should start slowing down. |
| Clay Buchholz |
SP |
BOS |
Ignoring upside isn't smart, but reaching extra for it, in this case, hides his in-play reliance and dropping K/9. BB/9 still WIP. Be careful. |
| Aubrey Huff |
1B/OF |
SF |
Every-other-year vet had some HR/FB fortune. Weak park, lineup don't facilitate another strong performance. This is why you address 1B early. |
| Delmon Young |
OF |
MIN |
Like Buchholz: Temper paying for upside. Many OF can give what Young can this year. 2010 value was RBI-fueled. Unlikely to repeat that. |
| Jonathan Sanchez |
SP |
SF |
BB/9 and WHIP improvements reulted in shaky numbers anyway. K's will be there, but playoff IP bump and lucky LOB%, BABIP spell harsh correction. |
Keith Hernandez
| Player |
POS |
TM |
The what for |
| Elvis Andrus |
SS |
TEX |
Thin SS class has many overpaying. Zero power and mediocre BA leave only SB potential as a reason for drafting. |
| Francisco Liriano |
SP |
MIN |
Last year was nice - but for 2H fade. Violent pitching motion makes him injury waiting to happen. Becoming property of Yanks wouldn't help his value. |
| Alfonso Soriano |
OF |
CHC |
A crowded outfield in Chi-Town. Also not good: Speed decline and all too frequent swings and misses. Pop still there, but only useful for OF depth. |
| Jonathan Sanchez |
SP |
SF |
Playoff run makes him look better than he really is. Low BAABIP last year and uninspiring BB rates don't excite me. Fly-ball allowance is still a problem. |
| Michael Bourn |
OF |
HOU |
Runs and SBs for sale here. If you're looking for more, look elsewhere. Don't expect his BA to return to '09 levels. |
Fantasy Baseball Editor's Choice:
Sleepers | Busts | Bargains | Rip-offs
Prospects | Veterans | Fantasy predictions | MLB predictions
About KFFL Staff

KFFL, part of USA TODAY Sports, has been turning fantasy sports players into winners since 1996!
We are your one-stop for all of your fantasy football, baseball, NASCAR, hockey and basketball needs all year long.
Don't miss these great reports....