KFFL's staffers choose their favorite 2011 fantasy baseball busts.
Tim Heaney
| Player |
POS |
TM |
The what for |
| Justin Morneau |
1B |
MIN |
Not putting myself in position to rely on him. Concussion history frightens me, not to mention his clockwork 2H fades |
| Elvis Andrus |
SS |
TEX |
How much does he stand out from, say, Rafael Furcal? It's an upside, faith pick; 'til Andrus shows me some power and BA, he ain't in my top 7 SS |
| Trevor Cahill |
SP |
OAK |
Isn't this a tired lesson? Sure, GB nice, but few K's. BABIP- and LOB-fueled success typically comes back to normal. He'll have growing pains, too |
| Pedro Alvarez |
3B |
PIT |
HATE to be this drastic, especially w/ his upside. At the right point, sure, I'd take him. But work ethic, BA issues keeping me from overspending |
| Matt Garza |
SP |
CHC |
Move out of AL East not an instant cure for FB, K/9 woes. BB/9 is his calling card, but HR/9 climbing. Now he's at Wrigley Field? Pass |
Keith Hernandez
| Player |
POS |
TM |
The what for |
| Jose Bautista |
OF |
TOR |
Likely on most people's lists, but we all know he won't repeat the 54 dingers. Thirty is possible, but weak BA to go with isn't worth the price. |
| Matt Garza |
SP |
CHC |
Guy is overvalued. Period. Forget about the no-hitter; his high FB% and HR/9 make the move to Wrigley scarier. No thanks. |
| Adrian Beltre |
3B |
TEX |
Is he really only 31? Already injured in ST. Contract year responsible for great '10 numbers? High BABIP last year will make him a huge BA disappointment. |
| Rickie Weeks |
2B |
MIL |
One healthy year shouldn't mask injury risk. No more updside now. Poor CT% and high K% make him a BA enigma. Doubt he will approach 30 homers again. |
| Jered Weaver |
SP |
LAA |
Dominance spiked last year; pay for a regression, not a repeat. Fly-ball allowance will raise his ERA to something closer to 3.50. |
Cory J. Bonini
| Player |
POS |
TM |
The what for |
| Grady Sizemore |
OF |
CLE |
Lingering concerns (even from Sizemore himself) about his knee; power in question, and SBs may not be there with a bum knee. |
| Derek Jeter |
SS |
NYY |
Dropped off in a major way in 2010; could be even worse entering an age-37 season; the risk isn't worth a potential minimal uptick in stats. |
| Trevor Cahill |
SP |
OAK |
Could make the overvalued argument, but a low K rate (5.31/9), a little bit of 2010 luck, a poor offense (again) and more tape on him have me worried. |
| Jorge Posada |
C |
NYY |
Expecting Russell Martin to outshine him; age, a decline in PA and injury concerns should be enough to scare you. |
| Jonathan Papelbon |
CL |
BOS |
Statistical trends in the wrong direction, could be traded during the season (may not be all bad); has Daniel Bard and Bobby Jenks waiting for his job. |
Nicholas Minnix
| Player |
POS |
TM |
The what for |
| Justin Morneau |
1B |
MIN |
Love the hitter, feel for the human being, but have little interest in a player drafted so highly who has to sit if a teammate pats him on the head after a HR. |
| Adrian Beltre |
3B |
TEX |
Something smells funny in Texas. Beltre is a rotten commodity on his own, when $ isn't on the line. Fear is that new location may only add to this lie. |
| Colby Rasmus |
OF |
STL |
Quality player, but have concerns about BA correction and repeat of HR rate, coupled with possible effects of turmoil in STL, poor relationship with skip. |
| Grady Sizemore |
OF |
CLE |
It's too soon to expect much more than tepid production in first action after microfracture surgery. Will be a target in 2012, maybe after the 2011 break. |
| Trevor Cahill |
SP |
OAK |
Can't knock the GB prompter who earns Brandon Webb comparisons, but Webb struck a few people out, didn't walk too many and posted realistic ERAs. |
Fantasy Baseball Editor's Choice:
Sleepers | Busts | Bargains | Rip-offs
Prospects | Veterans | Fantasy predictions | MLB predictions
About KFFL Staff

KFFL, part of USA TODAY Sports, has been turning fantasy sports players into winners since 1996!
We are your one-stop for all of your fantasy football, baseball, NASCAR, hockey and basketball needs all year long.
Don't miss these great reports....