Fantasy baseball sleepers, undervalued - OF

by Tim Heaney and Nicholas Minnix on March 25, 2013 @ 10:00:00 PDT


Pages 1 | 2 | all

Championships aren't won in the first few rounds of fantasy baseball drafts. Winning selections come in the middle and late stanzas, when fantasy baseball sleepers and undervalued players pop up.

Jason Heyward, Atlanta Braves

Arizona Diamondbacks OF Adam Eaton
Eatin' up Eaton

Heyward doesn't hit as well at Turner Field, and he still struggles versus left-handed pitching and in making contact. Don't expect .300 campaigns anytime soon without significant fortune.

Against southpaws, though, he added five homers and 32 BA points in more than double his 2011 sample - progress. Regaining strength in his right shoulder and retooling his swing erased bad 2011 memories and, more importantly, simply allowed him to hit the ball hard to all fields. (His boost in left-field in-play success was a major step.) His liner increase and noticeable drop in infield flies shows more authoritative connections.

Early indications say Heyward will hit second in a restocked lineup, which could lead to more swipes. Even with a tiny step forward, it's a dollar-collecting profile that could replicate a slightly cheaper version of Justin Upton. -TH

Shane Victorino, Boston Red Sox

Victorino hit only two home runs after his move to the Los Angeles Dodgers in 2012, and he batted just .255 for the season. That campaign is reminiscent of the downer of a year he had in 2010, when he rang up a career-high 18 jacks but batted only .259. The switch-hitter has been known to fancy himself a power hitter on occasion, and those times have been reflected more in his results than in his plate-discipline marks, but they're evident nonetheless. His worst numbers as a left-handed batter have come in those two years, too.

The fence at Victorino's new home yard won't tempt him to go up there hacking. In fact, Fenway Park may play significantly better for his speed when he puts the ball in play, which is still quite often. At 32, he isn't likely to steal 40 bases, but 30-plus is still easily within reach. His indicators against righties haven't deteriorated, despite his poor results against them in two of the last three seasons, so a more disciplined approach would yield a profitable season from Victorino. -NM

Nick Markakis, Baltimore Orioles

It's difficult to believe that the O's marched to the postseason in 2012 and Markakis wasn't a central reason for it. But that's primarily because he missed a month and a half with a broken bone in his wrist and then the rest of the season, including the playoffs, when he sustained a broken thumb about a week into September. This was after he'd undergone surgery to repair a torn muscle in his abdomen at the beginning of the calendar year and worked his butt off to be ready in time for opening day.

One thing Markakis, 29, isn't: injury-prone. Not because he came up against a couple of freakish injuries, anyway, including a small disc herniation in his neck that will delay his prep time; the team thinks he'll start 2013 on time. The left-handed hitter played in 157 or more games for five straight seasons before the last one. Although his body wasn't 100 percent last year, his outstanding control of the strike zone was intact, and he was experiencing a bit of a renaissance in his rate of round-trippers produced.

Markakis wasn't inclined to run last season, so there's no reason to expect double digits there, but this is a skilled, steady, quality hitter who's available at a good discount, otherwise, especially if your opponents overrate the severity of his latest setback. -NM

Ichiro Suzuki, New York Yankees

Was a move to the Bronx just what the veteran needed last season? Or were his improved results simply a product of the corrections due on a .261 average, four home runs and 15 stolen bases in 423 plate appearances with the Seattle Mariners? He hit .322 with five ding dongs and 14 thefts in a mere 240 plate appearances with the Bombers.

It's a little of both. Ichiro should spend half of his age-39 campaign in The House That Steinbrenner built, which is simply a big plus. Playing for a championship franchise certainly seems to have given his career a bit of a jolt, and although his physical ability has declined, he's aging gracefully. The health of Derek Jeter (recovery from fractured ankle) may even present Ichiro with some opportunities to lead off.

No one is urging you to pay for an easy .300 BA and 40 stolen bases any more. But his projection somewhat easily arrived at the possibility of double-digit home runs and another 30 swipes, and .280-plus is nothing to sneeze at. The market probably won't ask you to pay a lot for a good shot at those marks. -NM

Michael Cuddyer, Colorado Rockies

Cuddyer's first Mile High go-round was grounded by a season-ending oblique injury that cost him about two months. His splits weren't drastic, but you could tell he enjoyed Coors Field. His first half was typical Cuddy production; it's just that many 2013 drafters forget that he didn't have a legit chance to build on it.

Soon to be 33, he's not in any state of tangible skills upside, but profit earned simply from returning to 500-plus at-bats doesn't constitute a leap of fantasy faith in the middle rounds. Added bonuses, besides occupying one of fantasy's favorite hitter's parks: his additional first base eligibility and middle-of-the-order spot. -TH

Dexter Fowler, Colorado Rockies

Fowler took a major step - .293 BA, 10 of his 13 homers - inside the lefty batter's box. His power tapered off violently in the second half, but he still hit the ball hard for most of the year, including a 43.4 liner rate in August.

The next step toward a bigger payoff: extracting more base thievery from his 6-foot-4, 190-pound frame. The mass marks a buildup from more offseason workouts and may inhibit his ceiling, but the Rockies, so they've said, want him to run more and have called on the original Eric Young to help his larceny.

Fowler holds the "undervalued" tone, not "sleeper." But even if his clip dwindles, he'll offer four-category upside that could take a small step forward; doubters - there will be plenty - will help keep the investment reasonable. -TH

Adam Eaton, Arizona Diamondbacks

The power growth many expect from the desert gnat won't arrive in 2013 - that's probably a few years down the road. But his gap punch makes for a nice complement to his upside of consistent .300 clips and 30-steal seasons. He was making his mark in his debut stint last summer before he broke his right hand.

St. Louis Cardinals OF Jon Jay
Jay not boring

Sure, 'Zona has insurance in Gerardo Parra and, to an extent, Tony Campana in case Eaton must revisit the farm, even to start the year. But all things equal, Eaton seems most likely to have a hold on PT. He's excelled at taking a walk at every level of professional play; his aggressive but smart game should make his transition smoother than most speedsters' - perfect for a fourth or fifth option in a mixed league. -TH

Jon Jay, St. Louis Cardinals

The 10 homers he hit in 2011 were knocked down to four in a nearly equal statistical sample last year. But what Jay didn't offer shouldn't strip the extremely stable profile he's developing elsewhere; he's the best leadoff option in a potent lineup and finally cashed in on his speed in the column fantasy owners care about.

When filling out five-fly-catcher lineups, someone like Jay, turning 28 in March, hardly excites but most certainly stabilizes a squad's batting average, thanks to his acceptable batting eye and liner- and grounder-leaning distribution. With solid leather and stability versus southpaws, he's an almost guaranteed 500-plus at-bats of a clip boost. -TH

Franklin Gutierrez, Seattle Mariners

In both 2009 and 2010, Gutierrez played in 150-plus games, batted a combined .264, hit a total of 30 home runs and swiped 41 bases in all. He's played in 132 major league contests since. Roto managers will quickly dismiss him as an injury-prone mess.

It should be noted that the right-handed batter missed much of 2011 because of a debilitating illness, not an injury. In Gutierrez's effort to prove that he was ready to return last spring, he may have overdone it and invited the torn pectoral muscle that wiped out most of his first half. Naturally, once he returned, he sustained a concussion. Why not just give up, Guti?

The 30-year-old enjoyed his first healthy offseason in a couple of years, however. He was able to play winter ball in Venezuela, where he batted .349 with three home runs in 86 at-bats. The center fielder is still a valued, plus defender. Gutierrez should also benefit a bit from the drawn-in fences at Safeco Field. He could easily be a nice mixed-league supplement or profitable addition to an AL-only roster. -NM

Chris Parmelee, Minnesota Twins

The Twinkies have a mixture of All-Star-caliber major leaguers and Quad-A wannabes in their projected lineup. Parmelee, 25, has a shot to prove that he's not one of the latter because he's expected to begin the season as Minnesota's right fielder, a position he began to play regularly to close out last season. He could round out a deep-mixed roster or provide a cheap presence in an AL-only manager's outfield.

Parmelee's MLB lifetime numbers (.265/.336/.440 in 298 plate appearances) are representative of his abilities in a full campaign. He's gained good control of the strike zone and makes regular contact (80 percent or better), and he has the power to hit 20-plus bombs. Minnesota has little reason (i.e., no depth) not to give him a long - long - look in right field. And if you're really concerned about his PT, then rest assured that he's the likeliest in-house option at first base, should the Twins trade Justin Morneau. -NM

Facebook Twitter Google +

Pages 1 | 2 | all


Fantasy baseball sleepers, undervalued: C | 1B | 2B | 3B | SS | OF | SP | RP

Fantasy baseball busts, overvalued: C | 1B | 2B | 3B | SS | OF | SP | RP

About Tim Heaney

Tim's work has been featured by USA Today/Sports Weekly, among numerous outlets, and recognized as a finalist in the Fantasy Sports Writers Association awards. The Boston University alum, who competes in the prestigious LABR and Tout Wars, has won numerous industry leagues in both baseball and football.

He appears frequently, including every Sunday, on Sirius XM Fantasy Sports Radio, as well as every Wednesday on 1570 AM WNST in Baltimore.

Don't miss these great reports....

What do you think? Sound off!

Recent KFFL releases