Burning Fantasy Baseball Questions: Cincinnati Reds

by Tim Heaney on February 1, 2013 @ 13:15:00 PDT


Pages 1 | 2 | 3 | all

KFFL answers important fantasy baseball questions about each Major League Baseball team as spring training approaches. What must fantasy baseball players know about the Cincinnati Reds?

What will 2013 hold for Aroldis Chapman, starting pitcher?

As Jerry Crasnick reminds us, the Reds have planned for this since the defector's arrival in the States. He was primed to assume these duties last spring after a brilliant Cactus League run before Ryan Madson underwent Tommy John surgery; setup men incurred injuries; and Sean Marshall proved shaky at finishing contests.

Will the strikeout-laden Chapman perform as effectively with a comfort zone of 95ish mph as he did when pinning triple-digit readings every other pitch? He'll reach back when needed, but trying to do that frequently, while working to buck his high-walk trend from a starter's rubber, will be difficult. The fastball-slider approach needs a consistent tertiary component, at least, which involves restoring his changeup and/or splitter; each has nasty potential but needs more MLB polish.

An inadequate arsenal halted Neftali Feliz, whose difficulties in the role change contributed to his need for Tommy John surgery. Chris Sale's string pull, meanwhile, was his best pitch last year, in terms of 2012 PITCHf/x value. Jeff Samardzija's pre-existing abundance of pitches helped his cause, as well. Of course, Sale and Samardzija also use plenty of two-seamers to offer fastball variety. Chapman still has a monogamous relationship with four-seamers.

Cincinnati Reds SP Mat Latos
Cincy's next No. 1?

Unfortunately, hitters have been sitting on his stuff a bit more, even if the surface stats don't show it. His opponents' liner rate suffered a 3.3 percent jump from 2011 to 2012, per Fangraphs, to 19.8. Maintaining that suffocating look he's pulled off as a reliever will take more work. He may resort to an "effectively wild" fallback, which could lead to extended issues.

Don't forget the mental aspects of starting: adjusting to numerous turns through a lineup; holding runners on; fielding your position for five-plus stanzas; staying loose between innings; and communicating frequently and efficiently with catchers. In fairness, at least he was a starter in his Caribbean days, and despite questions of on- and off-field maturity, the higher-ups continue to praise his work ethic and adjustment to American life.

Cincinnati has various avenues for cultivation, whether by limiting his per-game tosses, starts or tenure on the active roster, or sliding him back into relief for a spell. With Mike Leake and others in tow, they boast a backup plan to make 2013 a productive step toward Chapman's long-term ace status. They don't want his progress cut short like Feliz's.

Words mean only so much over the winter, but pitching coach Bryan Price said bumping a workload "by 50 or 60 or 80 innings in today's standards would be considered irresponsible." Chapman logged 71 2/3 frames last year and dealt with a balky shoulder as autumn arrived, which adds to their incentive for continued caution. Even Dusty Baker, a fingered accomplice - justly or not - in the improper development of young pitchers, apparently doesn't want to overdo Chapman's responsibilities.

If Cincy, who looks like a strong postseason contender, locks things up early, they may choose to save him for the postseason. In that route, however, avoiding a Stephen Strasburg-like scandal will prove tricky.

Of course, if Chapman bombs this spring, he could easily slide back into the stopper job, pushing Jonathan Broxton to setup duty again. At this point, however, Cincy looks ultra-committed to this path. Chapman would have to melt down.

Fantasy drafters should recognize the promise and drawbacks with his first year of this change. Strikeouts are strikeouts, and at some point in the middle mixed rounds, they'll make sense to draft even if you're counting on only a 120-inning ceiling. As a fourth (more optimally, fifth or sixth) dual-universe SP, he has a good chance to yield positive returns.

Of course, the potential stumbles and absences mean not to pay for his long-term upside immediately; hype will prompt many to do just that, meaning next year looks like a better shot at productive ROI.

How safe are the Reds' other rotation members?

It's hard to justify citing Great American Ball Park as a reason to avoid their five-some. The Reds had a 3.51 team ERA there last year, which ranks in the middle of the big-league pack.

Nick's comparison of Johnny Cueto to Matt Cain may have resonated a tad with early mockers. The control-based Cincinnati righty has indeed shown ace-level skills - including a K/9 jump of more than one batter from his modest 2011 showing. He still labors a bit, and his 19 wins inflated his dollar gains, but his honed craft makes him a nice backup if you don't land or avoid targeting a true No. 1.

Mat Latos has even less buildup and stands to offer a more significant come-up. His dominance has dipped in each of the last two seasons, but he significantly improved each piece of his GB/FB ratio. He has the profile to keep high left-on-base percentages, as well, so you can't call the 75.5 percent from last year an utter fluke. With one of the best supporting lineups, he'll sneak below many draft radars with his top-10 starting pitcher potential.

Homer Bailey's schedule was pretty favorable during his late-season run, but here's a prototypical post-hype arm that finally has learned to pitch. He's joining his teammates in learning to adapt to his home park (hello, grounders). His command is worth a staff-capping spot in most leagues, and with the experience he holds heading into his seventh year of MLB action, there's plenty of breakout potential.

Bronson Arroyo's innings-eating, control-fueled, homer-allowing base experienced some positive regression last year, and he should continue to be a useful, in-season mixed rental.

Where did those Todd Frazier and Ryan Ludwick numbers come from?

Cincinnati Reds 3B Todd Frazier
Seek counsel in Frazier?

Frazier finally recaptured the promise he held several years ago as a position-wandering prospect. Ludwick has shown such runs before as a fringe lineup piece.

Leaving the yard remains the most stable skill for both hitters, and when you call GABP home, you can sustain it. The .316 BABIP Frazier put up resembled those he put up in the minors; his lumber produces many ropes, after all, and he doesn't have a drastic handedness split weakness. However, his fly-ball frequency and poor command of the strike zone say that even after the growth step in 2012, you shouldn't expect another clip boost. That shouldn't stop you, however, from giving him corner-infield consideration in mixed setups, especially since he's eligible at both qualifying positions. He's getting lost in the depth at each spot.

Ludwick's success versus right-handed pitchers gives him plenty of security as long as he keeps up a smidge of the summer run he posted. He's one of the streakiest stick wielders in the game, though, and any lows would open up time for Chris Heisey. Still, as long as he's in a run-producing role, Ludwick has a sound chance to match his counting contributions at a highly discounted price.

Facebook Twitter Google +

Pages 1 | 2 | 3 | all

AL East
Baltimore Orioles
Boston Red Sox
New York Yankees
Tampa Bay Rays
Toronto Blue Jays

AL Central
Chicago White Sox
Cleveland Indians
Detroit Tigers
Kansas City Royals
Minnesota Twins

AL West
Houston Astros
Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim
Oakland Athletics
Seattle Mariners
Texas Rangers

NL East
Atlanta Braves
Miami Marlins
New York Mets
Philadelphia Phillies
Washington Nationals

NL Central
Chicago Cubs
Cincinnati Reds
Milwaukee Brewers
Pittsburgh Pirates
St. Louis Cardinals

NL West
Arizona Diamondbacks
Colorado Rockies
Los Angeles Dodgers
San Diego Padres
San Francisco Giants

About Tim Heaney

Tim's work has been featured by USA Today/Sports Weekly, among numerous outlets, and recognized as a finalist in the Fantasy Sports Writers Association awards. The Boston University alum, who competes in the prestigious LABR and Tout Wars, has won numerous industry leagues in both baseball and football.

He appears frequently, including every Sunday, on Sirius XM Fantasy Sports Radio, as well as every Wednesday on 1570 AM WNST in Baltimore.

Don't miss these great reports....

What do you think? Sound off!

Recent KFFL releases